top of page
Student filling in standardized test sheet

April 2024

Comparing SAT, ACT, and GRE: A Comprehensive Guide to Choosing the Right Standardized Test for You


Standardized tests have long been a cornerstone in the landscape of educational assessment and admission processes worldwide. Among these, the SAT, ACT, and GRE stand out as pivotal benchmarks for undergraduate and graduate admissions, respectively. Each test serves a specific purpose, catering to different academic levels and disciplines. They evaluate a broad range of skills, from verbal reasoning and quantitative aptitude to specific subject knowledge. The significance of these tests extends beyond mere academic assessment; they are gateways to higher education and professional realms, influencing the trajectory of millions of students and professionals. This article delves into the intricacies of the SAT, ACT, and GRE, comparing and contrasting their proliferation, requirements, core materials, testing procedures, difficulty levels, and overall value in contemporary academic and professional landscapes.

Proliferation and Popularity

The SAT, introduced in 1926, and the ACT, first administered in 1959, have evolved significantly over the decades, both in content and reach. Initially designed to democratize college admissions and reduce reliance on preparatory schooling and socio-economic background, these tests have become almost ubiquitous in the United States' college admissions process. The GRE, introduced in 1936, serves a similar role for graduate school admissions, with a focus on assessing readiness for graduate-level academic work.

Today, millions of students take these tests each year. In 2019, about 2.2 million students took the SAT, while the ACT saw around 1.8 million test-takers. The GRE numbers are smaller but significant, with hundreds of thousands of prospective graduate students taking the test annually. These figures underscore the tests' widespread acceptance and the crucial role they play in educational and professional advancement.

The tests' popularity isn't confined to the U.S. Internationally, students aspiring to study in American institutions also partake in these exams, making them a global standard for academic evaluation. This international reach has further solidified their status, with preparatory courses and tutoring services proliferating worldwide to cater to this demand.

The demographic taking these tests is as varied as their applications, ranging from high school sophomores and juniors (for the SAT and ACT) to college students and professionals seeking advanced degrees (for the GRE). The broad appeal and necessity of these exams underscore their entrenched position in the education system, notwithstanding ongoing debates about their accessibility, fairness, and relevance in evaluating a student's potential for success in higher education.

Requirements of Each Test

SAT and ACT: For high school students eyeing undergraduate programs, the SAT and ACT are pivotal. Both require prior registration, either online or by mail, and come with a registration fee—$55 for the SAT and $60 for the ACT as of the latest updates, with additional costs for optional essay sections and late registrations. Fee waivers are available for eligible students, aiming to ensure that financial constraints don't bar talented students from taking these tests. The required documentation typically includes a recent photo and an acceptable form of ID.

GRE: The GRE, catering to a broader audience including international students, requires similar registration steps but with a higher fee of $205, reflecting its use for graduate-level admissions. The GRE also offers subject-specific tests, in addition to the general test, for those looking to highlight skills in particular academic areas. Documentation requirements are stricter, especially for international test-takers, who must present a valid passport as identification.

Age Requirements

There are no strict age requirements for the SAT, ACT, or GRE. These tests are designed to assess academic readiness rather than being contingent upon the test-taker's age. However, the typical demographic for the SAT and ACT ranges from 16 to 18 years, aligning with the tail end of high school education. For the GRE, test-takers are usually older, often in their early to mid-20s, as they are generally college graduates or individuals who have been in the workforce and are considering graduate education. Exceptions exist, with younger students sometimes taking these exams to qualify for gifted programs or early college admission.

Core Material and Structure


The SAT is structured around two main sections: Evidence-Based Reading and Writing, and Math, with an optional Essay section. The total testing time is 3 hours for the core sections, with an additional 50 minutes for the Essay. The Reading and Writing section includes passages and sentence completion tasks designed to assess comprehension and command of evidence. The Math section covers algebra, geometry, and trigonometry. The SAT emphasizes analytical skills, requiring students to apply knowledge rather than recall facts.


The ACT comprises four sections: English, Mathematics, Reading, and Science, with an optional Writing test. This exam lasts 2 hours and 55 minutes, with an extra 40 minutes for the Essay. Unlike the SAT, the ACT includes a Science section that evaluates interpretative and problem-solving skills in natural sciences. The ACT is known for its straightforward questions but tight timing, challenging students to manage their time efficiently.


The GRE General Test features three main components: Verbal Reasoning, Quantitative Reasoning, and Analytical Writing. The Verbal section tests vocabulary and comprehension through reading passages and sentence equivalence questions. The Quantitative section assesses basic math skills, understanding of mathematical concepts, and the ability to reason quantitatively. The Analytical Writing section, always the test's first part, measures critical thinking and analytical writing skills, requiring test-takers to articulate complex ideas effectively and with clarity. The GRE is unique for its adaptive test format in the Verbal and Quantitative sections, where the difficulty level adjusts based on the test-taker's performance.

Each test's structure and material are designed to evaluate a range of competencies expected at different educational levels. While the SAT and ACT focus on the breadth of high school curricula, the GRE delves deeper into critical thinking and analytical skills, reflecting the advanced understanding required for graduate studies.

Testing Requirements and Procedures


Testing Environments

The SAT, ACT, and GRE are typically administered in designated testing centers under strict supervision to ensure integrity and fairness. While the SAT and ACT are offered both in paper-based and digital formats in some regions, the GRE is primarily computer-based, with a paper-based option available only in areas lacking the necessary computer facilities.

Identification and Security

All three tests require valid, government-issued identification, with stringent requirements for international test-takers, particularly for the GRE. Security measures include the use of metal detectors, surveillance cameras, and the prohibition of personal items in testing rooms. These protocols ensure a controlled environment, minimizing the potential for dishonesty and ensuring that the results accurately reflect each test-taker's abilities.

Difficulty Comparison

Comparing the difficulty of the SAT, ACT, and GRE is subjective, as it often depends on the individual's strengths, educational background, and preparation. Generally, the GRE is considered more challenging due to its advanced content and adaptive testing format, which increases in difficulty as the test-taker answers questions correctly. The SAT and ACT are perceived to be less difficult but not necessarily easier, as they test a wide range of high school-level knowledge and require strong test-taking strategies due to their broad content and time constraints. Preparation for these exams is crucial, with many students dedicating several months to study and practice to achieve competitive scores.

Value and Necessity

Educational and Professional Impact

The SAT and ACT are crucial for undergraduate admissions in the U.S., with many colleges and universities requiring scores from one of these tests as part of the application process. Similarly, the GRE is a common requirement for graduate programs, especially in the U.S., serving as a benchmark for assessing applicants' readiness for graduate-level studies.

Criticism and Debate

Despite their importance, these tests have faced criticism over concerns about accessibility, fairness, and their ability to predict academic success. Critics argue that standardized tests may disadvantage students from lower socioeconomic backgrounds who may not have access to extensive test preparation resources. In response, some institutions have adopted test-optional policies, allowing applicants to decide whether to submit SAT, ACT, or GRE scores.

Future Outlook

The value and necessity of standardized tests are likely to remain subjects of debate. However, as the educational landscape evolves, these exams continue to adapt, incorporating more equitable testing practices and digital formats to stay relevant and accessible to a diverse population of test-takers.


Standardized tests like the SAT, ACT, and GRE play significant roles in the academic and professional paths of millions worldwide. While each test serves a distinct purpose and presents unique challenges, their ultimate goal is to assess the readiness of individuals for the next stage of their educational or professional journey. As debates about their fairness and relevance persist, the evolving nature of these exams suggests a future where they may better reflect the diverse capabilities and backgrounds of test-takers, ensuring that educational and professional opportunities remain accessible to all.

Further resources: 

bottom of page